Activate an optimized version of the page designed specifically for screen readers.
Outdated browsers can expose your computer to security risks. To ensure a secure experience, we recommend updating to the latest browser version. Support for this browser version will soon be discontinued.

Were findings successfully, qualitatively reproduced?

Were you able to successfully reproduce the qualitative results reported in the paper?


Did you modify or 'tweak' the originally described protocol in your attempts to reproduce it?

     'tweak' = small procedural variations within the scope of what was described in the paper

     'modification' = procedural variations beyond the scope of the experimental description in the paper

How complete was the experimental description?

What percentage of steps and/or materials in the reported method were omitted, vague, or ambiguous?

How sensitive was the experimental outcome to any incompletely described steps or materials?


Was your experimental methodology modified from the paper's descriptions by any previous OJER reviews?

How much expertise do you have in the particular field of this experiment?